Skip to main content

Poverty Has the Indelible Face of Dignity



In a recent article published in the Las Cruces Bulletin, Christopher Erickson, Ph.D., a professor of economics at New Mexico State University concludes that after “50 Years, U.S. War on Poverty largely won.” Actually, the struggle against the effects of poverty has been waged for many centuries before President Johnson’s well known 1964 State of the Union address in which he declares “war on poverty,” Dr. Erickson makes a myopic and mistaken conclusion that poverty equates with the condition of  “malnutrition”.

The larger condition of “poverty” is a much more complex phenomenon than Dr. Erickson’s simplistic equation of “Poverty equals malnutrition.” Political declarations of war on the condition of poverty are at best rhetorical and skim the surface of what is required to act responsibly toward our neighbor in affliction. Two thousand years ago Jesus of Nazareth recognized that the poor will be with you always. (Matt 26:11) Christian tradition teaches its members that true justice concerning the poor is derived from the remarkable cornerstone of an intrinsic dignity of the human person seen by Jesus Christ. Neither the Church nor secular humanitarian approaches have ever reduced understandings of poverty to be physical hunger alone. 

Various modes of governance have approached alleviation of poverty in public policy as part of the governance’s responsibility for the “general welfare.” “The poor” are not a faceless class to be easily forgotten, ignored and treated as political pawns in the chess game of prosperity. For this reason, Judeo-Christian traditions have approached the problem of injustice and its effects proactively and in the front lines. Only by such face to face interaction can we be compelled to reflect upon the poor as individuals with an indelible dignity and right to freedom. The success of our endeavors regarding poverty rides heavily upon what we consider to be just action in regard to human dignity under the weight of affliction. This is the role the Catholic Church has championed for so long. Christians and humanitarians alike, lunge at the high goal of alleviating and even eliminating poverty as a condition. Regardless of faith perspective, we must attempt to alleviate the condition of poverty to the individuals who suffer its ramifications: hunger, loneliness, homelessness, depression, disease, prejudice, alienation, violence, among many others.  The “fish net” underlying the Christian perspective toward the poor is that there is no shame or net loss to the inherent dignity of those who suffer it. Rather, the poor have faces and names. They rise to a special status and are to be interacted with as Christ’s “little ones” (Luke 6:20) as a priority.

The present reality of poverty in America defies draconian equations like “poverty equals hunger.” The condition of poverty arises from underlying societal injustices. To be sure, it is both an individual and a societal problem. Injustices of any kind assault human dignity. In the wake of injustices, the poor starve for more than food. The poor starve for fairness, opportunity, work, and especially recognition of their given dignity as children of God. In the end, such a war must be fought by each of us as a matter of personal and ethical responsibility to act cooperatively answering “yes” to the question: “Am I my brother’s keeper?” Or better yet, let’s keep in mind the parable of the Good Samaritan as the model of determining “who is my neighbor” in response to the commandment that we “love our neighbor as ourselves.” (Luke 10:25-37)(Lev 19:13)

The poor live and struggle within our own back yard here in southern New Mexico. I interview individuals and families who present their cases to Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Las Cruces. I witness the specter of homelessness, unemployment, underemployment, and substandard living. I am not alone in this to be sure. A quick tour of some of the colonias in our own southern New Mexico area will very quickly give a dramatic picture that impoverished conditions are real. The number of people availing themselves of soup kitchens and food banks is growing in southern New Mexico. In spite of it oil rich resources, educational institutions, and defense related research laboratories, the southernmost 10 counties of New Mexico are considered among the poorest in the nation. The colonia communities of Columbus, Vado, Anapra, and Chaparral are remote geographically to be sure. However, those who live in these communities are further alienated by virtue of their present struggle to thrive even in the most prosperous nation on earth. Our public policy indecision relative to immigration from Mexico and Central America has intensified and complicated these effects locally.

The Church’s 2000 year old war has never been on poverty, but rather, upon the specter of social injustice. Ultimately, such a war is waged within each of us to stop or lessen our individual and societal proclivity to harden our hearts toward our neighbor in need. Pyric victories as declared by Dr. Erickson result in an individual and societal blindness to reality, or worse, an indifference to it. Christianity, other main stream religious traditions, and even secular humanitarianism, demand vigilance against this tendency.

Reference Material:

The Church’s love for the poor... is a part of her constant tradition.” This love is inspired by the Gospel of the Beatitudes, of the poverty of Jesus, and of his concern for the poor. Love for the poor is even one of the motives for the duty of working so as to ‘be able to give to those in need.’” [Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2444]

The Church has to play her part through rational argument and she has to reawaken the spiritual energy without which justice ... cannot prevail and prosper". (Pope Benedict XVI, Deus Caritas Est, 28) According to Pope John Paul II, the foundation of social justice "rests on the threefold cornerstones of human dignity, solidarity and subsidiarity." (Bl. Pope John Paul II, 1999 Apostolic Exhortation, Ecclesia in America, 55) 

Catholic Church teaching zeroes in on what individual, social, political and economic foci should be: “In its various forms—material deprivation, unjust oppression, physical and psychological illness and death—human misery is the obvious sign of the inherited condition of frailty and need for salvation in which man finds himself as a consequence of original sin. This misery elicited the compassion of Christ the Savior, who willingly took it upon himself and identified himself with the least of his brethren. Hence, those who are oppressed by poverty are the object of a preferential love on the part of the Church which, since her origin and in spite of the failings of many of her members, has not ceased to work for their relief, defense, and liberation through numerous works of charity which remain indispensable always and everywhere.”248 (386, 1586)(Emphasis added)[Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2448]

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

September 11, 2001, A Tuesday, Not a Day Like Anyother

  On September 11th 2001, a Tuesday, I was set to fly to Washington, D.C. for the first gathering of the inductees to the Excellence in Government Fellows. We were to meet on Wednesday, September 12th at the Willard Hotel for the initial ceremonies and series of week long events for those of us from across the nation who were to participate. I originally had my flight on the Monday before, September 10, but decided to switch my flight. If I had departed that Monday, I would have been in the middle of it all. I remember getting up early that day since the American Airlines flight was to depart from Albuquerque for Atlanta at 8 a.m. with a connecting flight to Ronald Reagan International in D.C. later that afternoon. It was still dark outside when my Red 1998 Dodge Ram Quad Cab pulled into the extended parking area. I travel light so I had two bags. Took the shuttle from extended parking and the sun still was not near its rising point. It was about 6 a.m. I got to the airport, and

El Tejedor del Alma

          Desde el momento en que puedes recordar, te han dicho que tienes un alma. A diferencia de un cuerpo, no podemos ver un alma. No podemos ver, con nuestros ojos, el alma. Y aunque sea invisible, lo sentimos adentro. Usemos palabras como "corazón, mente y alma" como si fueran una trinidad de ingredientes para quienes somos totalmente.           No podemos ver nuestro propio corazón a menos que veamos imágenes en un sonograma. Aunque no podemos ver la mente, podemos ver un cerebro a través de instrumentos médicos. Pero el cerebro solo -- no es la mente. Pero la mente es más que eso. Incluso más allá de la mente, la mente única que eres, hay un componente aún más elevado que llamamos alma. Como un arte de alfareros, cada mente y cuerpo moldeados -- son únicos debido de este espíritu inimitable que es el alma.           Los místicos del pasado, incluidos los de la época anterior a la venida de Jesús, hablaron sobre este misterioso ingrediente de "quiénes som

Pro Life Saint Doesn't Have to Be Saintly to the Devil

[In Response to an Opinion Piece in the Albuquerque Journal by   JOLINE GUTIERREZ KRUEGER / JOURNAL STAFF WRITER Tuesday, May 28th, 2019 at 12:02am https://www.abqjournal.com/1320926/prolife-saint-not-saintly-to-all.html?fbclid=IwAR3Hrl8HMhaTp64k4c9RVLZ3KnC5V9YEFvn2WKDk_ch1kWrGw55XKx6B1i0 Whether Phil Leahy is a truly saintly man may indeed be a matter of opinion, but that he had the right to stand and voice his beliefs in accordance with laws, is without question. And no one had a right to do violence upon him because of a difference of opinion. A good journalist would have recognized that right; and a journalistically trained editorial writer would have defended Mr. Leahy’s right. To mimic the headline of the “Leahy is not a Saint at all” article, Southwestern Women's Options Clinic is not a clinic to all. It doesn’t heal. It destroys. Its perpetrator, Dr. Curtis Boyd is no Doctor either. He destroys late term babies that will have their futures ended by having the